Rich & craggy
Appalachian Rocky Road
Chocolate, toasted almonds, marshmallow, and trails of dark and white chocolate chips.
- Chocolate
- Toasted almonds
- Marshmallow
Sweet Beginnings Society Our first 50 members $42/month
North Georgia's monthly cookie club
Big cookies.
Little moments.
The first bite. The last crumb. A quiet moment that's all yours.
Six generous, small-batch cookies. Three rotating flavors. Baked for slow mornings, shared tables, and a little sweetness every month.
6 cookies / 3 flavors 4–5 oz each Hiawassee pickup
Inside the monthly box
October's three
sweet stories.
October’s box is warm, nostalgic, and a little wild—the kind of autumn trio that disappears before the coffee gets cold.
Two of each flavor. One for now, one for later—if you can wait that long.
A little happiness to unwrap
Open the box.
Make a moment.
Put the kettle on. Pick your first cookie. Save one for someone you love—or settle in and keep this moment for yourself.
Each box includes six individually wrapped 4–5 oz cookies, the month's illustrated flavor card, and care and reheating notes.
Stay a little. Savor a little.
Some things deserve
a slower moment.
Break off a piece. Let the chocolate linger. There's no occasion required—just your favorite mug, a comfortable spot, and something baked with care.
Comfort in every crumbGenerous cookies, seasonal flavors, and a handmade touch.
A reason to pauseA monthly ritual to look forward to, long after the box is empty.
Even sweeter togetherShare a cookie and a little time with someone you love.
How it works
Join once.
Enjoy a box each month.
Sign up for six months of cookies. Pay monthly, and pick up one freshly baked box each month at VC Coffee in Hiawassee—we'll share the date and pickup window ahead of time.
Choose your membership
Confirm who the box is for and complete the short signup flow.
We bake your monthly box
Three rotating flavors are selected, baked, and packed into one beautiful box.
Pick up something good
Collect your fresh box at VC Coffee in Hiawassee during the monthly pickup window.
For our first 50 members
The Sweet Beginnings Society.
Be part of something sweet from the very first batch. Our first 50 members become founding members of The Sweet Beginnings Society—and will always hold a special place in the Byrd & Butter story.
- Exclusive founding-member discounts
- A special Sweet Beginnings Society gift
- Opportunities to vote on new flavors
- Early ordering access
- A special birthday treat
Here's to quiet moments, fresh-baked goodness, and sweetness worth slowing down for.
COOKIE CLUB MEMBERSHIPSweet Beginnings Society
$42 / month
Six-month commitment · Hiawassee pickup
- 1Details
- 2Pickup
- 3Payment
The fine print, made simple
Questions,
answered.
Everything you need to know before your first box lands.
Have another question? Contact usWhat is The Sweet Beginnings Society?
Our first 50 members are the founding members of The Sweet Beginnings Society. Founding members receive exclusive discounts, a special Society gift, opportunities to vote on new flavors, early ordering access, and a birthday treat.
What comes in each monthly box?
Six oversized cookies—three rotating flavors, two of each. Every cookie is approximately 4–5 ounces and individually wrapped.
How does the six-month commitment work?
Your membership is $42 per month with a six-month minimum commitment. After the initial term, the membership continues monthly until canceled.
Where do I get my box?
Monthly boxes are picked up at VC Coffee, 375 N. Main Street B, Hiawassee, GA 30546. We’ll email the pickup date and window ahead of each month’s pickup.
Can I send the Cookie Club as a gift?
Absolutely. Choose “A gift” during signup and add the recipient’s name before secure checkout.